Honing vs sharpening
A knife that feels dull is often not worn out. Its edge has simply rolled over. Honing pushes it back. Sharpening grinds away metal to make a new edge. Knowing which one you need saves steel, and saves the knife.
What the makers say
| Honing | Sharpening | Source | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What it does | "realigns the microscopic teeth on the edge" | "takes a small amount of steel off the blade, creating a new edge" | Wüsthof |
| Metal removed | "does not create a new edge, and it does not remove metal" | "removes metal from the blade, it should be done only when the knife truly needs it" | Shun |
| How often | once a week to every day, by use | about once a year for many home cooks | Shun |
| How often | every few uses | once or twice a year | Victorinox |
| How often | weekly | two to three times a year | Global (UK) |
Honing: keep the edge in line
In use, a fine edge bends to one side. It still has plenty of metal; it just isn't pointing straight down anymore. A honing steel pulls it back into line. Wüsthof's instructions: rest the steel's tip on a non-slip surface, tilt the knife to 14° (10° for Asian-style knives), and draw it from heel to tip, alternating sides six to eight times. Shun builds a 16° guide into the hand guard of its steel. Victorinox says to hold the blade at 20° to the steel.
Not every rod is a honing rod. Shun separates the two clearly: its honing steel "won't take material off your blade," while its ceramic rod "will take material off" and should be used "more sparingly." Shun also warns against using a diamond steel for regular honing on its knives. Wüsthof sells both honing steels and sharpening steels. It recommends a honing steel for regular maintenance and a sharpening steel when the knife needs an edge reset.
Sharpening: make a new edge
When honing doesn't bring the edge back, the edge itself is worn: rounded, chipped or too thick. Then you need to remove metal, on a stone, a guided system, a pull-through or an electric. Shun puts the switch point simply: "When your knife is dull and honing no longer provides improvement, it's time for sharpening." Sharpening at the knife maker's angle keeps the edge geometry the same. The angle finder shows that angle for your brand.
A simple routine
- Feels dull? Hone first, at your knife's angle.
- Test it. Slice a sheet of paper; the Chef'sChoice 4643 manual says a sharp edge should cut it smoothly. More tests in how to tell if a knife is sharp.
- Still dull? Sharpen. The grit selector or the sharpener finder helps.
- Chipped, cracked or a broken tip? See hone or sharpen. Large damage goes to the maker or a pro.
Common mix-ups
- "My steel isn't working anymore." A honing steel can only realign an edge that's still there. Once the edge is rounded or chipped, no amount of honing helps; Shun's rule is to sharpen at that point.
- "I hone with a ceramic rod, so I never sharpen." Shun says a ceramic rod removes material, so it's light sharpening, not just honing. Shun says to use it "more sparingly."
- "Any angle will do for honing." Makers give one: Wüsthof 14° (10° for Asian-style), Shun 16°, Victorinox 20° to the steel. Honing at the wrong angle can roll the edge instead of straightening it.
- "Pull-throughs hone." Some have a ceramic finishing slot that works like light honing. Their carbide or diamond slots sharpen and remove metal. Check which slot the manual means.
Why it matters
Every sharpening shortens the life of the blade a little. Honing doesn't. A knife that's honed regularly needs sharpening less often, which is the point of Shun's "hone for maintenance, sharpen for restoration." The schedules makers suggest are compared in how often to sharpen. The ways a sharpener can remove too much metal are in do knife sharpeners ruin knives?.
FAQ
- Does a honing steel sharpen a knife?
- A plain honing steel doesn't. Shun says honing doesn't create a new edge and doesn't remove metal. Shun adds that its ceramic rod does take material off, so it sharpens as well as hones.
- How often should I hone?
- Shun says some cooks hone once a week and others every day, depending on use. Victorinox suggests honing every few uses; Global's UK site says weekly.