As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Some links on this page are affiliate links — if you buy through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Read our affiliate disclosure.
These two sit at opposite ends. An electric sharpener gives you a fixed angle in a few seconds with no skill. A whetstone gives you any angle and any finish, but you hold the angle yourself. Your knives decide most of it.
Side by side
Whetstone (e.g. Shun 1000/6000)
Electric (e.g. Chef'sChoice 1520)
Angle
Any, held by hand
15° and 20°, fixed
Abrasive
Water stone, 1000 / 6000
100% diamond plus stropping disks
Narrow Japanese edges (under 14°)
Yes, at the maker's angle
No setting that low
Single-bevel
Not stated by Shun for this stone
Yes, procedure in the manual
Serrated
Not stated
Yes
Ceramic knives
Not stated
No (manual)
Prep
Soak before use
Plug in; no water or oil (manual)
Effort
Practice; several minutes per knife
A few pulls per stage
Warranty
not published
1-year limited (manual)
Choose a whetstone if…
Your knives have narrow or unusual edges, such as Miyabi's 9.5–12°, Wüsthof's Asian-style 10° or a single bevel.
You want to choose the finish, from a 400-grit repair to a 6000-grit polish (see the grit chart).
Your knife maker advises against electrics. Global's UK site says it doesn't recommend them.
Choose an electric if…
Your knives are at 15° or 20° and you want the job done in a couple of minutes.
You'd rather not learn to hold an angle.
You also have serrated knives the machine's maker allows.
The two picks
Premium · whetstone (water stone)
Shun Combination Whetstone 1000/6000
any, held by hand
2 stages
Serrated: not published
Good fit for: Japanese knives at their own angle; restoring a dull edge, then polishing.
Variant
SSM0600
Type
whetstone (water stone)
Angles
any, held by hand
Abrasive and grit
water stone (1000 / 6000)
Stages
2
Serrated knives
not published
Ceramic knives
not published
Single-bevel knives
not published
Power
manual
Water or oil
water — soak before use
Warranty
not published
Limits: no coarse side for chips; angle is held by hand; stone must be soaked first.
Shun factory edge is 16° per side (Shun FAQ); angle is held by hand.
Skip it if… you want a sharpener with a fixed angle; your knives are chipped.
A pull-through is like an electric without a motor: fixed angle, few pulls. A whetstone sharpens at any angle you hold, with a wider choice of grits, and takes practice.
Do electric sharpeners remove more metal than whetstones?
Global (UK) says electric sharpeners 'tend to strip a lot of metal off the blade' and doesn't recommend them. Other makers don't publish a comparison.
Specs verified: November 2026 · Updated 2026-11-18 · How we choose